(CNN)A new football study has found that a small change in one area of the sport — kickoff rules — may lead to a significant reduction in concussion rates.
A research letter published Monday in the medical journal JAMA said that after the Ivy League athletic conference changed its rules in 2016 to move the kickoff and touchback lines in games, there was a reduction in the concussion rate among players.
Specifically, the average annual concussion rate in the college conference was 10.93 per 1,000 plays during kickoff before the rule change. It dropped to 2.04 after, the researchers found.
“What that translates to is about a 69% reduction in the rate of concussion,” said Douglas Wiebe, first author of the research letter and a professor of biostatistics and epidemiology at the University of Pennsylvania’s Perelman School of Medicine.
In comparison, the researchers found that for other play types, the average annual concussion rate was 2.56 before the rule change and 1.18 after, which was not a significant difference.
“To see that rate of concussion went down that much, very strongly in kickoff returns relative to other types of plays over the same period, we think it’s an example of a public health intervention that was part of a large collaboration between injury epidemiologists and coaches and athletic trainers,” Wiebe said.
The kickoff return play poses a risk of concussion — a type of traumatic brain injury caused by a blow to the head — because it involves players running at speed toward each other over a long distance, the researchers noted.
In 2015, kickoffs accounted for 6% of all plays but 21% of concussions in the Ivy League conference, the researchers said, referencing data published in the journal Injury Prevention.
The next year, the rule change called for moving the kickoff line from the 35-yard line to the 40 and the touchback line from the 25-yard line to the 20.
Small change tied to significant reduction
For the study, researchers analyzed data from the Ivy League’s concussion surveillance system, identifying concussions occurring during in-conference regular season games from 2013 through 2017.
The Ivy League itself includes eight schools: Princeton, Dartmouth, Yale, Columbia, Pennsylvania, Harvard, Brown and Cornell.
The researchers evaluated each concussion by what type of play caused it and when it occurred, whether before or after the 2016 rule change.
Researchers: 96% of ex-NFL players had brain disease
The rule change was introduced as an experiment, Wiebe said.
“They weren’t sure what was going to happen, but they thought it had a chance to be protective,” he said.
The research had some limitations, including that the kickoff rule changes were only in the Ivy League, and so the findings may not generalize beyond the conference.
Also in 2016, another new rule eliminated full-contact hitting in practices in an effort to reduce overall injury rates.
“This rule likely did not differentially affect activities during different types of plays during competitions and hence would not bias this analysis,” the researchers wrote in the study.
As part of that initiative, “something that was surprising — not surprising but exciting for us — is that we have enough data that we’re really able to look at this outside of a case by case basis and that we’re able to look at this over the course of several years after the rule was put in place,” said Bernadette D’Alonzo, a co-author of the new research and a clinical research coordinator at the University of Pennsylvania’s Center for Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics, and the Penn Injury Science Center.
‘Preventing concussion is much easier than treating concussion’
The study was “well-done,” and the findings “make sense,” said Dr. John Leddy, a primary care sports medicine physician and clinical professor at the University at Buffalo in New York, who was not involved in the study.
“It shows just how powerful rule changes can be in preventing concussions,” said Leddy, who is also medical director of the University at Buffalo Concussion Management Clinic.
“That’s important because you’re going to get concussions in football, but if you can develop rules that reduce the risk, then preventing concussion is much easier than treating concussion,” he said.
He added that more research could help shed light on whether other rule changes in football have been or could be associated with reductions in concussion.
For instance, “what the Ivy League and other divisions in NCAA football have done is limit the amount of contact in practices, because some of the concussions occur during the practice week, not just in games,” he said.
It’s too early to attribute the fall in concussions seen in the new research to just one rule, said Joseph Clark, professor of neurology and rehabilitation medicine at the University of Cincinnati who was not involved in the new research letter.
He called the recent findings “a step in a positive direction” but added that more work needs to be done.
“Other research has shown similar falls in concussion rates even before the 2016 rule changes,” he said. “Finding out what rule, policy, culture, practices, education, et cetera, will help mitigate concussions will take a bit more work than examining one rule change.”
Social Interest Freak LightDesktop Software Fully Compatible for PC and Mac that uses the latest API to allow laser-targeting of Facebook/Instagram Ads at a level that's never been possible before for the Average Joe or Jane, Small Business Owner/Entrepreneur.
DFY Member Special Bundle 2EXTRA SPECIAL OFFER: Bundle of Video Overload Plugin, 10 Done For You Membership Sites and Extensive Email Copywriting Course at Super Low Price
Livematic [Monthly]LIVEMATIC is an all-in-one cloud based software that helps you engage your audience with LIVE VIDEOS Simultaneously on Unlimited Profiles; Unlimited Groups And Unlimited Pages. You can also use your pre-recorded videos as Live Broadcasts on ALL Your FB Pa
LeadPrimo EliteWorld’s ONLY All-In-One Email Marketing Platform That Creates Beautiful Lead Pages and Send UNLIMITED Emails Directly into Inbox to Get You More Clicks and Open Rates Without Paying Any Monthly Fees FOREVER.
SyndBuddy 2k mthlyPage 1 Rankings For BOTH Video and Niche Sites Made EASY With Our Social Exchange Platform
LiteApp Studio - Reseller [50 Licenses]Get Rights To Resell 50 Licenses Of LiteApp Studio and keep 100% of thee profits [Costs you only $2.54 per license for the 50 pack and you sell each for $97. Make over $9500 in profits reselling your licenses!]
Confident Power Rock Premium EasyTrackConfident Power Rock is a ultra-high energy EasyTrack with a powerful metal rock style that expresses and creates a confident and motivational mood. This EasyTrack can be used with Easy Audio Lab (included at no additional cost) to create a variation of t
MailPrimo EnterpriseWorld's No.1 and Most Powerful Cloud Based Email Marketing Software to make them STOP Losing their Leads, STOP Paying Heavy Monthly Fees and Generate More Leads, Gets them Better Delivery, More Opens and Clicks completely hassle free...
TweetPush Elite One TimeTweetpush lets you reply, retweet and engage with all your twitter account followers from one interface on automation. Tweetpush can get you marketing intelligence data and find you qualified leads by monitoring specialized keywords, hashtags for new twee
Progressive Apps Builder Reseller's EditionWorld's Easiest Progressive App Maker. Convert Your Website into A Progressive App and Send Instant Push Notification to your customer on their Smart Phones. No App Store Approvals Required.
21 Laws of Persuasion (Taboo)The 21 Laws of Persuasion is a 100+ page .pdf that explains the laws of Influence and Sales Psychology with plenty of detailed instructions, real-world examples, and case studies.If your subscribers are interested in the Power of Persuasion and how to a
Tee Titan Resell RightsRare as a gold-plated unicorn. Get resell rights to the best-selling Tee Titan offer. LIMITED. ACT NOW.
ATL - DIAMOND Upgrade - LITEThe Affiliate Traffic Lab is a 100% cloud based software that creates traffic getting videos that you can rank on Google and Youtube in minutes to get you free traffic, leads and sales.
IM Checklist Volume 7: Newbie Marketer18 Step By Step Online Marketing Checklist. Comes in PDF, Spreadsheet, Editable Doc's, Mindmaps and Online Forms. 1 Hour Of Video Training Included. PLR Rights Included.
Viral Reach Elite MonthlyViral Reach is a Facebook marketing 100% automation tool. Once you type in the keyword Viral Reach will get you content from high-authority and non-spammy sources for maximum organic reach and post it on its own.Get the full variety of content including t
Hughand#39;s Software and Mentoring Group Monthly MembershipWith our monthly membership you get: a) Downloads, Developer Licensing and Training for ALL of our software products, including new ones we add on a regular basis. b) Hundreds of hours of archived training, c) weekly live calls with Hugh. GREAT VALUE
NinjaShoppe EliteThe MOST POWERFUL App on Planet That Builds a Fully Functional Affiliate Shoppe in 60 Seconds Flat That Gets You Products from Top E-com Giants, Unique Content, Video Reviews, TRAFFIC and COMMISSIONS, All Hands FREE…
VidZio Affiliate Store BuilderVidzio is a player that let you make sales directly from your videos… Customers can shop and watch at the same time without ever leaving your video or even hitting pause, you're leading them from engagement, to product, to purchase.
NinjaShoppe Unlimited StoreThe MOST POWERFUL App on Planet That Builds a Fully Functional Affiliate Shoppe in 60 Seconds Flat That Gets You Products from Top E-com Giants, Unique Content, Video Reviews, TRAFFIC and COMMISSIONS, All Hands FREE…
MaticPress ContestAre you struggling to create high-quality and rich-content website? With this brand new WP theme, now you can build rich-content website without creating any single of content... Build viral niche sites, drive free traffic, build list, and make money on c
Designa Suite [Theme Club]Get 500 Stunning, Bang On Trend, Ready-to-edit, Professional Design Templates
Added To Your Account Plus 30 New Delivered To You EVERY! SINGLE! MONTH!
LIVEreel - CLUB-liteLIVEreel CLUB-lite gives you access to 50 video templates, thousands of stock images, icons, fonts and motion background video clips.
APS Elite Members Package+The APS Super Simple Squeeze Page Builder Software
+10 templates and Giveaways
+The Auto Profit System Solo Ad Mastery Guide
+The APS Follow up Email Sequence
Stockocity 2 ProfessionalUnlimited access to Stockocity 2 Professional including 18,000 FHD footage videos and 250 new FHD videos per month for 24 months. (note this is an upgrade to Stockocity 2 - you cannot purchase this product unless you have purchased Stockocity 2)
IM Video Masters UpgradeLIMITED TIME SPECIAL - Lifetime Access To IM Video Masters Wth Over 30 Training Videos. Full 30 Days Money Back Guarantee. Instant Access.
Online Sales Pro MVP LifetimeGrow Your Sales with Online Sales Pro. The lead generation, marketing automation, and direct sales software tool that has helped over 45,000 customers grow their leads, sales, and cash flow.
ProfitBuilder - LeadsFlow ProThe Ultimate SuperCharger for ProfitBuilder - LeadsFlow Pro Integrates, Tracks and Manages All Your Leads From One Simple Dashboard and Automates Major Parts of Your Business...
Viddictive LiteViddictive Lite instantly adds 20+ templates to your account.
YouTube Music Videos for Fun and ProfitYouTube Music Videos For Fun And Profit is an in-depth training course that teaches people how to use popular music videos from major bands and artists to make money legally. Music is the most popular niche on YouTube and is full of lucrative opportunitie
Video ToolChestVideo ToolChest is a collection of 10 main tools and some tools can be used for multiple purposes. Each tool provides a solution for a problem we've been asked about repeatedly by users of our other applications and by users of video and animation tools b